We Wear the Mask

The Mask and What It Costs

“We Wear the Mask” is a poem about the cost of survival. The mask — the performance of contentment, the grin that hides the grief — is what Black Americans had to wear in white America in order to be permitted to exist. It was not a choice but a necessity, and its necessity was itself a form of violence: the forced suppression of the true self in the interest of the comfort of those who had the power to make survival contingent on the performance.

The poem’s theological depth lies in its final address: “But let the world dream otherwise, / We wear the mask.” The world dreams that the grin is genuine. The poem insists that it is not — that beneath the mask there is a real self, a real grief, a real cry “to Christ” that the world does not hear.

What Sympathy Reveals

“Sympathy” — the poem from which Maya Angelou took the title of her autobiography — is Dunbar’s most direct account of the condition of the caged bird: “I know why the caged bird sings, ah me, / When his wing is bruised and his bosom sore.” The bird sings not for joy but because it must — because the song is the only freedom available to a creature whose body is confined.

This is the condition of the dialect poetry that made Dunbar famous: poems that performed the contentment and the simplicity that the white reading public wanted to see, written by a man who felt the cage and knew it, and who sang because there was nothing else to do.

The Seed of the Woman

Genesis 3:15 describes a conflict in which the seed of the woman is bruised — in which the victory comes at the cost of a wound. Dunbar’s life is a document of that bruising: a man of extraordinary gifts whose gifts were channeled by the culture he inhabited into forms he could not fully accept, who died of tuberculosis at thirty-three, who knew the cage from the inside and named it with a precision that has lasted more than a century.

His cry to Christ in the mask poem is not the cry of a man who has found the answer but of a man who knows where to look. The God who hears the cry of the masked, who sees the face behind the grin, who knows the grief that the world dreams otherwise — this God is the answer to the condition Dunbar describes. Whether Dunbar fully found him is between Dunbar and God. But the cry was real, and the God to whom it was addressed is real enough to receive it.

Leave a Comment