The Legend and the Lord

The Mythological Imagination

Irving’s two greatest stories — “Rip Van Winkle” and “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow” — are not realistic narratives but legends, and they work the way legends work: by rendering in narrative form a truth about human experience that realistic fiction cannot quite capture. Rip Van Winkle sleeps through his life and wakes to find that the world has changed beyond recognition; the story is about the nature of time, loss, and identity in a way that no realistic account of a man who slept for twenty years could be. The Headless Horseman may or may not be a real ghost; but the terror he represents — the irrational, the inexplicable, the darkness that lurks at the edge of the ordered world — is entirely real.

This is what legends do: they render the shape of reality by departing from its surface. They are not lies but a different kind of truth. Irving understood this instinctively, and his use of the legendary mode is one of the things that distinguishes his best work from the realistic fiction of his contemporaries.

What The Legend of Sleepy Hollow Reveals

“The Legend of Sleepy Hollow” is, among other things, a story about the limits of rationalism. Ichabod Crane is a man of learning — a schoolteacher, a reader, a believer in the power of education — who is destroyed by something his learning cannot explain or protect him from. Whether the Headless Horseman is a real supernatural entity or a costumed rival, the effect on Ichabod is the same: the rational world he inhabits is not the only world, and his inability to account for the irrational leaves him helpless before it.

This is Irving’s implicit critique of the Enlightenment confidence that reason is sufficient to navigate reality. The darkness at the edge of Sleepy Hollow is not abolished by learning. It waits, patient and implacable, for those who think that the only real things are the things that can be measured and explained.

The Seed of the Woman

Genesis 3:15 describes a world in which the darkness is real — in which the serpent’s work produces real terror, real loss, real disruption of the ordered human world. Irving’s legends are not Christian documents, but they testify, in their own way, to the reality of that darkness and to the inadequacy of purely rational responses to it.

Rip Van Winkle wakes from his long sleep to find everything changed; the world he knew is gone. This is a parable of the human condition in the fallen world: the world we were made for is not the world we inhabit, and the gap between them is experienced as loss, as disorientation, as the sense that something essential has been missed. Irving renders this condition with a lightness of touch that disguises its depth. But the depth is there, and it is the depth of a condition that only the seed of the woman can finally address.

Leave a Comment