Sixty Stories

The Catholic Ruins

Barthelme’s statement that “fragments are the only forms I trust” is not a neutral aesthetic position. It is a theological one: the confession that the unified vision — the vision of a world held together by a coherent story, a coherent God, a coherent moral order — is no longer available. The fragments are what remain after that vision has collapsed.

What makes Barthelme significant for TLA is that he knows what the fragments are fragments of. His Catholic formation gave him a precise sense of what wholeness would look like — and therefore a precise sense of what is missing.

What The Dead Father Reveals

The Dead Father is Barthelme’s most sustained theological allegory — a novel in which a massive, still-partially-living figure called the Dead Father is dragged across a landscape by a group of characters toward a destination that turns out to be his own burial. The Dead Father is God, or the idea of God, or the authority of the Father in all its forms.

The novel is funny and bleak in equal measure, which is Barthelme’s characteristic mode. The freedom purchased by the death of God turns out to be the freedom to drag a very heavy corpse across a very long distance.

The Seed of the Woman

Genesis 3:15 describes a conflict that requires the living God, not the dead father of Barthelme’s novel. What Barthelme’s fiction documents — with a precision and honesty that is itself a form of testimony — is what happens when a culture tries to live on the memory of God rather than on God himself: the fragments multiply, the comedy becomes increasingly melancholy, and the dead father gets heavier with every step.

Barthelme could not write his way out of the Catholic imagination that formed him, and his fiction is the record of that inability. The fragments he trusted were the shards of a wholeness he could not forget and could not recover. That inability is itself a witness to the reality of what was lost.

Leave a Comment